RepOne Consulting
CPM Scheduling | Construction Expert

Hyperbolic Structure Case Study: Museo Soumaya

In my recent post The Ups and Downs of Hyberbolic Structures, I discussed modern day manifestations of Vladimir Shukhov’s hyperbolic structures. My determination was that despite a handful of negligible examples, no structure has been built that equals the structural genius, integrity, and simple aesthetic of Shukhov’s towers, especially his Moscow tower.

In my research, I came across several examples of dubious enterprises. I also proposed that James Carpenter’s Sky-Reflector Net, at the New York Fulton Street Transit Center Pavilion, was a worthy homage to Shukhov’s work, despite the inverse engineering techniques; suspension vs. tension. This nuance is likely never encountered to the untrained eye.

museo soumaya

Somehow, in researching hyperbolic structures, I missed the Ove-Arup/Gehry over-engineered Museo Soumaya (2011), in Mexico City. The Museo was designed by the owner’s son-in-law, and named after his wife. It came to my attention when I noticed a corner of it jutting into a photo of the recently built Museo Jumex, and I was intrigued. The structure houses the $700M trophy-case art collection of the world’s richest man, Carlos Slim. It was budgeted at a paltry $38M to build, but was realized for $70M; a negligible sum for the owner. The museum was received relatively coolly by the press, and I fear some impressions were restrained due to antipathy for the perceived arrogance of Mr. Slim, and his alleged nose for bargains rather than tasteful art acquisitions.

I immediately noticed the similarity of the building to the Carpenter Sky-Reflector Net, and was initially drawn to the structure’s Lady Gaga-like corset. It is more attenuated and severe at its wasp-waist mid-section than Carpenter’s work, and at 150′, about twice in height. The 16,000 honeycomb panels echo the diamond panel treatment of Carpenter’s net. Like the Sky-Reflector net, the Museo Soumaya also features an oculus, to let in natural light, which is the only source of natural light on the windowless structure. An early rendering suggests that windows were at least at one time considered (click image to see note upper left).

museo soumaya

 

 

 

 

 

 

However, the view upwards is gummed up by the cacophony of supporting beams resembling a horizontal ferris wheel.

museo soumaya

 

 

 

 

 

 

Unlike Carpenter’s work, the hyperbola is not symmetrical. It also differs from both Carpenter’s and Shukhov’s work in that it is neither constructed in suspension (Carpenter) nor tension (Shukhov), but in compression, composed of 28 curved steel vertical columns and seven beams.

museo soumayaAt the end of the day, we realize that whether a hyperbolic structure be designed in tension, compression, or suspension, none have matched the simple integrity of Shukhov’s Avant-Garde achievements. Given advances in lightweight concrete and carbon structural materials, and enhanced designs created by BIM models, I believe that we haven’t seen the last of great hyperbolic structures.

 

Archives: 2014 - 2024

On the Adoption of AI Construction Scheduling Platforms

Recently, there have been some exciting developments in the field of AI construction scheduling platforms – such as the generative  “optioneering” platform offered by Alice Technologies*: the...

The Politics of CPM Scheduling

I think of politics in CPM scheduling primarily as an apt euphemism for sleight of hand reporting and representation of what contractors are either incapable of, or unwilling to give, accurate and...

Construction Disruption Claims & How to Optimize Them

In comparison to delay claims, construction disruption claims are a slippery slope when it comes time to make a claim. That’s because delays have finite start and end dates, where there is no work...

MEP Coordination Strategies

It’s been almost 10 years since I published my 4 part series on MEP coordination, and I thought “what better way to commemorate the occasion than with an update.” In that time a lot has changed and a...

CPM Schedule Oversight Best Strategies

CPM schedule oversight is a concern of both contractors and stakeholders.  Contractors should know what to expect from oversight consultants when they submit their schedules for approval. It...

CPM Schedule Specifications & Requirements: are they a waste of paper?

CPM Schedule Specifications & Requirements are generally found in CSI division 01 32 00 Construction Progress Documentation of a project manual or specifications, where they are routinely ignored...

Construction Completion Schedules for Accurate Closeout

  Nothing quite resembles the mad scramble contractors do to close out the final segments of their projects. By this time, the project schedule has likely been deprecated into a chaotic parallel...

Construction Bid Schedules: What They Are and Why Contractors Should Use Them

In requests for pricing (RFPs) or invitations for bids (ITBs) there are a number of requests or requirements that typically fall under the radar. One such is a seldom observed request generally known...

AI Generative-Design Poised to Displace 90% of all Architects and Why That May Be Good News

AI generative-design may prove to have unexpected benefits to the building industry. By improving the quality and developmental integrity of construction drawings, error and omissions will be...